AMIR SIADATFilm critic · Articles & reviews

BRIEF ENCOUNTER

Not Yet!

3 min read

“Are you ready?” “Not yet!” We have grown accustomed to comparing Mike Leigh with Ozu. But last night, watching his new film—specifically during the collective singing meant to lift the old man’s spirits—I thought of Kurosawa and that simple exchange in Madadayo, repeated who knows how many times, amid jokes and laughter, between the former students and their ageing teacher. It did not occur to me then that this, too, was a film about ageing and death, and that it had become its late director’s farewell.

Continue reading

ARTICLES

A Comparative Study of Vancouver’s Reflection in Two Eras: Bitter Ash and Out of the Blue

18 min read

Both "Bitter Ash" and "Out of the Blue" reflect their respective eras, focusing on countercultures in Vancouver. They explore themes like generational conflict, rebellion, and responsibility, with music—jazz in Bitter Ash, punk rock in Out of the Blue—highlighting their cultural contexts. The films also examine how people interact with urban space, showing a mutual influence between identity and the city.

Continue reading

BRIEF ENCOUNTER

Magellan (Lav Diaz)

3 min read

Conquering and superior peoples, when turning their victories into epic tales, generally need the appeal of mainstream cinema — and sometimes a wide screen to hold crowds and battles. But the new historical film by Lav Diaz about Ferdinand Magellan seems to go in the exact opposite direction; aside from the fact that its square frame limits space for ado and spectacle, it seeks, through stillness, quiet, and silence, to achieve an alternative approach — one that carries the perspective of the inferior.

Continue reading

BRIEF ENCOUNTER

Mirors No. 3 (Christian Petzold)

3 min read

Christian Petzold continues to explore substitute identities and enjoys twisting familiar conventions to make well-known stories feel strange and new. Mirrors No. 3 is another stop along his familiar path. Seen from a distance, this path gently leaves behind the city with all its noise, history, and twists, settling instead into the quieter suburbs and the lives of simpler people.

Continue reading

BRIEF ENCOUNTER

Kinds of Kindness (Yorgos Lanthimos)

3 min read

Raymond, by repeatedly interrupting Robert and asking him to leave and return before continuing the conversation (or to speak once while standing and once while sitting), is somehow designing the mise-en-scène. It’s as if he’s also conveying something about the director's visual style and logic to the audience. It seems that, at the same time, he is revealing something about the director's perspective and approach.

Continue reading

BRIEF ENCOUNTER

Monster (Hirokazu Kore-eda)

3 min read

The scene where the school officials bow to Minato's mother, showing no reaction to her distress other than expressing regret, encapsulates the overall message of Monster. In this moment, Kore-eda positions the camera to allow the audience to look down on these officials, highlighting the absurdity of this well-known aspect of Japanese behavior.

Continue reading

BRIEF ENCOUNTER

Poor Things (Yorgos Lanthimos)

2 min read

It appears that Lanthimos used his recent fairy tale as a vehicle to reflect on the arduous journey women have undertaken to secure their rights. However, can this reaction be considered inherently feminist as as many critics have suggested? I have my doubts. While the narrative, similar to Pinocchio, revolves around themes of maturity, it diverges from Pinocchio in that the protagonist does not emerge as a wise and informed individual after completing her journey.

Continue reading

BRIEF ENCOUNTER

The Zone of Interest (Jonathan Glazer)

3 min read

Last year, as I watched the documentary Lynch/Oz, each idea presented regarding the influence of The Wizard of Oz on Lynch's works resonated deeply with me. I found myself marveling at the creative and unconventional mind behind Lynch's works. Even when confronted with a lighthearted and whimsical piece, his ability to extract profound and strange effects is truly remarkable.

Continue reading

BRIEF ENCOUNTER

Anatomy of a Fall (Justine Triet)

3 min read

I do not remember the last time which character in which movie got on my nerves as much as the prosecutor in Anatomy of a Fall think his comments were annoying to me because I had almost assumed Sandra was innocent until the middle of the movie. Perhaps the reason for this initial antipathy- which eventually turned into admiration and respect - was that the prosecutor analyzed the aspects of the "scene" that I had carelessly passed by, with sharper eyes and with more sensitive eyes.

Continue reading

BRIEF ENCOUNTER

Tchaikovsky's Wife (Kirill Serebrennikov)

3 min read

Feminist critics may raise concerns regarding the title 'Tchaikovsky's Wife,' emphasizing the importance of acknowledging the main character's individual identity and name within the context of the film. However, the film persuasively conveys Serebrennikov's deliberate choice of a compelling and attention-grabbing title. After watching it, I kept thinking about the figure of the mad lovers of the cinema one by one, and I found myself pondering which character's narrative was infused with such egregious elements as selfishness, self-deception, and ultimate destruction?

Continue reading

BRIEF ENCOUNTER

Afire (Christian Petzold)

3 min read

The setting appears initially reminiscent of Eric Rohmer's world, with its vacation spot by the beach, a forest-bordered residence, and the intricate dynamics between friends and couples. However, the encroaching fire, blazing at a distance from the coastal scene, gradually disrupts the serene balance of this familiar universe. It becomes evident that the flames are not merely external to the characters' environment but rather ignite from within the narrative of Leon, emerging from the depths of his wounded psyche.

Continue reading

ARTICLES

Cristian Mungiu and the Trauma of Communism

23 min read

In a famous scene from Tarkovsky's Mirror, after making sure that there was no mistake in proofreading of the newspaper, the mother relaxes under the shower to wash away the toxic thoughts that have disturbed her mind during the past hours. Her look and facial expressions show both peace and disturbance together. She laughs and cries at the same time; Laughter because the danger is no longer exists, and crying because she knows that illusions are still standing and disasters are lurking.

Continue reading